Project Evil: The Evil Continues

From: Bill Paul (wpaul_at_FreeBSD.ORG)
Date: 01/25/04

  • Next message: Bill Paul: "Re: Project Evil: The Evil Continues"
    Date: Sat, 24 Jan 2004 19:49:00 -0800 (PST)

    Previously, I had asked for help getting the Intel Centrino wireless
    cards to work with Project Evil, and thanks to various wonderful people,
    a couple of Centrino cards and a miniPCI-to-PCI adapter turned up on
    Project Evil Labs' doorstep. The Centrino NDIS driver now works
    correctly. (The problem turned out to be that I wasn't initializing
    some special flags in ndis_packet structures).

    Now I'm trying to get a handle on getting support done for all
    the remaining unsupported 802.11 chipsets out there. There are a
    couple that I know don't work, and a few which might work, but I
    don't know for sure since I don't have them.

    Right now, it looks like all of the Broadcom-based cards should be
    supported, as well as the Centrino cards. There are various ethernet
    cards that I've tested which work as well. I am looking for success
    or failure reports concerning the following devices:

    - nVidia MCP ethernet, integrated into the nVidia nForce2 chipset.
      This driver should work using the nvenet.sys driver for Windows
      which is available from nVidia's web site. Note: recent versions
      of the driver consist of just two files: the nvenet.sys binary
      module, and its accompanying .inf file. However some of the older
      driver distributions included a couple of additional firmware/microcode
      files that nvenet.sys would try to load at runtime. If you have one
      of these older drivers, put the firmware/microcode files in
      /compat/ndis, and the driver should load them correctly.

    - RealTek RTL8180 wireless LAN chipset. I have been unable to find
      a card with this chip in any of my local computer stores. The
      RealTek driver for this chip _should_ work. I'm pretty sure all
      of the routines it calls are implemented.

    - ADMtek 8211 wireless LAN chipset. This one should also work, but I
      can't find any cards with this chipset in my local computer stores.

    - Intel PRO/5000 wirless card. This is apparently an Atheros 5210
      chipset. I have been told the wl50nd5.sys driver for this card
      crashes when you call its reset method, but again I don't have one of
      these so I can't confirm this or figure out what the problem is.

    - AMD Am1771/Am1772 wireless LAN chipset. This one probably won't
      work: the supplied AMD driver calls lots of functions in ntoskrnl.exe
      which I haven't implemented yet. This chipset is present on the
      SMC 2602w version 3 card. I repeat: that's the SMC 2602w VERSION THREE.
      The version 1 card is a Prism chipset. I don't know what the v2 card is.

    - Texas Instruments ax100 chipset. I'm not sure if this one works or
      not. This chipset has been reverse-engineered and there is a native
      FreeBSD driver available, but I'm still curious to see if it works
      with the NDISulator.

    - Atheros chipsets. Of course, we have the ath(4) driver to support
      these, but it would be nice to know which ones work (or do not work)
      with the NDISulator.

    - Any other PCI or cardbus NIC that I've overlooked which isn't currently
      supported by an existing native driver.

    If you have a system with one of these chipsets, please give the
    NDISulator a try. Note: you do NOT have to recompile your kernel to
    test it. Find the .sys and .inf files from your Windows driver media
    and do the following:

    # cp foo.sys foo.inf /sys/modules/if_ndis
    # cd /sys/modules/ndis
    # make; make load
    # cd /sys/modules/if_ndis
    # ndiscvt -i foo.inf -s foo.sys -o ndis_driver_data.h
    # make; make load

    You don't even have to reboot. Well, not unless the driver causes
    a panic. :/

    If the NIC works, that's great! Drop me a line letting me know, so I
    can cross it off the list. If it doesn't work, please do the

    - Describe the failure to me _in_ _detail_. DON'T LOAD THE DRIVER
      WITH X RUNNING. (I hate it when people do that. If for some reason
      there's a panic, you'll never see it unless you're watching the
      console. If X is running, it will just look like the system froze,
      and you won't be able to tell what happened.) If you see messages
      of the form "No match for <ConfusingWindowsFunctionName>" on the
      console, then the driver is trying to call some functions that I
      haven't implemented yet. In very rare cases, the driver may still
      work, but don't bet on it. Make a note of all console messages that
      appear when you try to load the driver module. And send them to me,
      along with a description of what card you have and whar Windows driver
      module you used.

    - Tell me where you got your card so I can try to get one too. As with
      the Centrino, it's not always possible to debug these problems without
      actual hardware.

    - If you're feeling really generous, loan me your card for a while so
      I can coerce^Wcoax it into working. (This doesn't apply to NICs
      that are integrated into your system.)

    Again, we at Project Evil appreciate your assistance in our efforts
    to dominate^Wimprove the world. If you decide to loan us your hardware,
    please send it do:

    Attn: Bill Paul
    Wind River Systems
    500 Wind River Way
    Alameda, CA. 94102

    Project Evil: when it absolutely, positively has to be evil overnight.


    -Bill Paul            (510) 749-2329 | Senior Engineer, Master of Unix-Fu
            | Wind River Systems
                  <adamw> you're just BEGGING to face the moose
    _______________________________________________ mailing list
    To unsubscribe, send any mail to ""

  • Next message: Bill Paul: "Re: Project Evil: The Evil Continues"

    Relevant Pages

    • Any luck with Netgear MA521 (Realtek RTL8180L)?
      ... I'm trying to get a new Netgear MA521 802.11b card working in Woody. ... chipset and some have apparently had success with it in various distros. ... and using gcc 2.95.4 and the RH7.3 version of the driver. ...
    • RE: [UPDATED PATCH] EFI support for ia32 kernels
      ... >> reuse a single driver image for multiple architectures assuming there ... As one of the people responsible for the EFI Specification and our ... Perhaps the UNDI network card interface that Intel developed ... BIOS can't shadow that much ROM code. ...
    • Re: Belkin Adapters
      ... Why is it advisable to install the software first? ... Because otherwise it can find a generic driver for the same chipset ... When I was having problems installing a 300 mbps express card because ... It uses a Realtek chipset. ...
    • Re: Wireless Network Cards
      ... >> Your biggest problem will be to find out what chipset a specific card ... I don't know what chipset is uses, but I bought a Linksys WMP54G card. ... which chipset your card uses and install the driver manually. ...
    • Re: Does FBSD 7 support 802.11N cards? G suggestions?
      ... under FBSD 7. ... Try and look at the card. ... asking shop clerks which chipset a card uses only ... Unpack the driver and read the .inf files. ...