Re: Router upgrade....

On Wed, Apr 26, 2006 at 05:48:03AM -0500, Matthew D. Fuller wrote:
On Wed, Apr 26, 2006 at 10:02:29AM +0200 I heard the voice of
Tyrone.VanDerHaar@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx, and lo! it spake thus:

I would like to upgrade the OS to 6.1RC1 to get the better support
for CARP on VLAN interfaces.What would the best way be to upgrade
with minimum downtime?

If it were me, I'd just upgrade the box as-is by buildworld; 5 and 6
are close enough that major problems aren't too likely (of course,
this is 'in general'; a single occurance of a major problem isn't much
globally, but it sure does hurt when it happens to you ;). Unless
something goes wrong, your downtime is two reboots.

I think you're forgetting the time sat in single-user mode while doing
installworld and manually mergemaster'ing the rc scripts. For an experienced
admin who has done this many times, it might just be a couple of minutes.
For someone who hasn't done it before, it could be a long outage.

Personally I prefer the other option suggested by the OP:
- build a brand new router using whatever O/S and software revisions you
choose to be on
- test it to death standalone
- configure it as a replacement and swap it in

If you want it to come up on the same IP address then you may have to clear
ARP caches on some other devices on the same LAN segment(s), but that's
about it. Most importantly, you have a very clear rollback available to you.
I challenge anyone to rollback a "make installworld" :-)

If you are being really clever, you bring it up on different IP address,
then let it take over the traffic (e.g. by participating in OSPF or
whatever, and then the other machine drops out). If there are machines
pointing defaultroute at the old box, then you swap IP addresses between the
boxes. Anyone who has not picked up the new MAC address will still send
traffic via the old box until its ARP cache expires, at which point it will
start using the new. If you are using CARP/VRRP or whatever, it's just a
question of changing the preferences and preemption.

This "smooth" approach may not be practical in your network though (e.g. if
you have a zillion VLANs hardwared into one router or the other)

Regards,

Brian.
_______________________________________________
freebsd-isp@xxxxxxxxxxx mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-isp
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "freebsd-isp-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxx"

Relevant Pages

  • Re: Router upgrade....
    ... I would like to upgrade the OS to 6.1RC1 to get the better support ... for CARP on VLAN interfaces.What would the best way be to upgrade ... with minimum downtime? ... are close enough that major problems aren't too likely (of course, ...
    (freebsd-isp)
  • problem upgrading from FC3 to FC4
    ... When I try to do an upgrade from FC3 to FC4, ... Error enabling swap device hde5. ... The /etc/fstab on your upgrade partition does not ... Mail has the best spam protection around ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: Cant upgrade: "Multiple devices with the same label"
    ... The fix was to run "swapoff -a" to turn off all swap, then, for each swap ... > I boot the FC6 installer, get to anaconda where I can select the ... > upgrade, and I get a dialog box that says: ... > label printed in the dialog box. ...
    (Fedora)
  • no swap makes system slower - why?
    ... Since upgrade to gutsy, I found the overal performance much better than ... swap partition was off, as well as my /boot (I use LVM ... evms package. ...
    (Ubuntu)
  • Re: OT: Mobile Phones and Insurance - any experts?
    ... As part of the upgrade, she now has a new sim card. ... surely you could just swap the SIMS back over to avoid having to trot ... Check if domestic contents insurance covers the phone. ...
    (uk.rec.motorcycles)