Re: Why are so many people using 4.x?



Michael Hughes wrote:

PII machine. Am I better off using an older version for such old
equipment? If so, do any particular versions stand out?

I use vinum on two of my machine and most of what I have seen on the
list about gvinum isn't good. That is the main reson I haven't
upgraded.

Is there anyone out there using gvinum on 6.x that can shed some light
on how well it is working now?

Finally an interesting point.
vinum is not supported anymore after 5.3 or so and was bound to be replaced by gvinum, which AFAICT is not that ready for production use. I'd be happy if anyone could prove me wrong.

There are alternatives, though: apart from hardware RAID, gstripe and gmirror provide RAID 0 and 1. We are still without any software replacement for RAID 5, AFAIK.
Bear in mind that, in order to do an upgrade, you'll have to backup, start from scratch, and restore.


So, to summarize:
_ building a new machine only has a show stopper if you intend to use software RAID 5; in that case you might want to use 4.11, but this is gonna have many downsides;
_ upgrading a 4.11 software RAID 5 machine is going to be some hell;
_ upgrading a RAID 0 or 1 vinum box can really be done, but needs some times;
_ upgrading an HW RAID/no RAID box or building a new RAID 0/RAID 1/HW RAID/no RAID box poses no problems at all.

bye
av.
_______________________________________________
freebsd-questions@xxxxxxxxxxx mailing list
http://lists.freebsd.org/mailman/listinfo/freebsd-questions
To unsubscribe, send any mail to "freebsd-questions-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxx"



Relevant Pages

  • Re: fc5: install everything?
    ... Just as Bruno mentioned for upgrading with raid where at least the updating is done singularly and the raid updated after the installation is completed. ... If the upgrade failed with the singular disk being updated, you would still have the redundant drive to start over. ... Apart from the Languages packs, we ALWAYS install everything here, as most of our PCs go out to clients. ...
    (Fedora)
  • Thanks Paul -- Formerly: Can anyone recommend a MB?
    ... running and the P4P800-SE is great (w/ 2 gigs RAM). ... Now I can look forward to upgrading my ... RAID0 ... AGP, 4xDDR, PCI slots, USB2 ports. ...
    (alt.comp.periphs.mainboard.asus)
  • Re: RAID 10 still best for DBs?
    ... Well a SAN is highly likely, ... databases in each and each maiailbox store in on a RAID 10 partition. ... We use to have them on RAID 5 at it was very slow sometimes, ... You will not be upgrading that server to 2007. ...
    (microsoft.public.exchange.admin)
  • Re: RAID 10 still best for DBs?
    ... databases in each and each maiailbox store in on a RAID 10 partition. ... We use to have them on RAID 5 at it was very slow sometimes, ... We are going to be upgrading our server soon, would RAID 10 be the best way? ... Number of disks you have at your disposal is key to spreading th I/O ...
    (microsoft.public.exchange.admin)
  • Re: State of gvinum RAID-5
    ... from NetBSD to FreeBSD (with gvinum) again. ... somewhat unstable Samba than an unstable Raid, ... Mike Squires ... However, there is one thing you should know: Never, ever, edit the gvinum config file directly when you want to remove drives from your array. ...
    (freebsd-questions)