Re: simh emulator and cluster

From: Stanley F. Quayle (stan_at_stanq.com)
Date: 05/12/03


Date: Mon, 12 May 2003 14:56:47 -0400

On 11 May 2003 at 22:12, David J. Dachtera wrote:
> Please approach this with great caution until you have made very certain
> that there is no danger to your production systems.

I concur. Once your SIMH machine enters the cluster, it must respond
promptly to all cluster messages. You might hack SYSGEN parameter
RECNXINTERVAL bigger on all cluster members, but that would make any
cluster transition longer.

One downside of how SIMH works is that it puts the Ethernet adapter
into promiscious mode. This means the adapter will "hear" absolutely
everything on the network, and the host system will have to process
each message. If that process "falls behind", you will have big
problems. The inevitable cluster failure might be the worst of your
problems. [Shameless commercial plug: CHARON-VAX doesn't do this.]

A work-around would be to install a second Ethernet adapter on your
system and configure SIMH to use that adapter. Make sure your host
doesn't start any other services on that adapter, and put it behind a
switch or router that filters all the non-SCS traffic. This is
easier said than done, however, since most switches and routers don't
know anything about SCS.

As for having the cluster members use the host's disk space, you will
have to serve a bunch of disk images from SIMH. Only those images
you share will be visible to the cluster members, and cannot be
combined into a single volume.

Might I suggest a better idea? I assume that you have TCP/IP
installed on these VMS systems.

Instead of emulating a VAX, why not use NFS to serve your host's
entire disk to the VMS systems? I do this myself, using a Linux
system to serve a 130 GB disk for my VMS cluster (both VAX and Alpha)
to use for backups, etc.

If you mount the disk correctly, using the /ADF=CREATE parameter, you
can have the VMS systems use the NFS share and they'll create hidden
files which preserve the VMS file characteristics. All you need to
do is to configure in the NFS client on the VMS systems, and you
should be good to go.

--Stan Quayle
Quayle Consulting Inc.

----------
Stanley F. Quayle, P.E. N8SQ +1 614-868-1363 Fax: +1 614 868-1671
8572 North Spring Ct. NW, Pickerington, OH 43147
Preferred address: stan@stanq.com http://www.stanq.com



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Windows 2008 server - disk reserved
    ... adapter Local Area Connection* 11 and node mail4.test.com adapter Local Area ... Failed to online cluster disk 0 from node mail3.test.com, ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.clustering)
  • Re: Problems with Virtual Test Environment setup
    ... the second adapter earlier, but I must have mixed up the numbers and it ... Disk Array so it can be used/included as a Cluster resourse. ... Make sure you add the SCSI adapters. ...
    (microsoft.public.sqlserver.clustering)
  • SUMMARY: changed WWID on cluster member boot disk
    ... disk and quorum disk of a single-member cluster, ... I could no longer boot from the cluster disks, ... the pre-cluster stand-alone system disk; ... the root1_domain on LUN containing the member boot disk was found ...
    (Tru64-UNIX-Managers)
  • Join an existing cluster
    ... I had a cluster setup with 2 computers running windows ... shared disk array. ... Creating a dummy Local Quorum resource. ... on the same storage bus as the boot disk... ...
    (microsoft.public.windows.server.clustering)
  • Re: Creating a wide area VMS Cluster
    ... > My goal is to provide a disaster tolerant cluster for both OS and data. ... disrupting the balance of the effect of votes between sites A and B. ... You have the option of a single shadowed system disk between the ...
    (comp.os.vms)