Re: Boot Error on Shadowed Sys Disk.



I dont think the problem is a "path definition" issue, several
successful boots had already been done, and even on the failed boot,
the booting system had a) found the device, b) read in the system
parameters and bootstrap code, and joined the cluster (as the correct
system).

I do however, think your first sentence pinpoints the issue, i.e. "must
have access to all shadow members at boot time". My logic goes like
this.

At the lowest level, the boot path is just a path to a "raw device",
and until the new node "joins" the cluster, the other nodes (and
processes running on them) are unaware of the new node. Once the new
node is "a member", and the other nodes recognise his presence, the
situation changes.
For example, the node which is up and which is controlling the
shadowcopy, may recognize that some process is trying to access the
system disk, but will not (or maybe cannot) concede access because the
new node may not yet have a SHADOW_SERVER process to talk to.
This being the case, the controlling node might conceivably put the
disk in "Mount Verify" until the situation is resolved.
The resolution would likely only occur if
1) The booting node time's out/bugchecks, hence stops trying to
access the disk.
2) The shadowcopy ends, taking away the restriction and allowing the
booting node access.
3) The Mount Verify times out resulting in (probably) the ejection of
the disk which is the target of the copy and then to option 2.

does this make any sense, and more importantly, does it have any
validity???

Dave

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Advice on Hard Drive Error
    ... WD probably has a disk checking utility, ... If you are able to boot you may be able to run this. ... > I've been having trouble booting XP (stops after XP splash ... > My mind is like an ocean ...
    (microsoft.public.windowsxp.hardware)
  • Re: Not quite happy with Ubuntu... What should I try now?
    ... particular disk could be bad. ... or 'bad' disks -4- with ub, you can also check the media before booting ... or Zenwalk); still could boot both. ... smooth progression from booting a windows> booting a windows or a linux ...
    (alt.os.linux)
  • Re: How best to boot a sick G4 Pmac ?
    ... The internal disk may be damaged too much. ... Repair permissions will not repair any disc directory damage. ... I had a G4 that wouldn't boot in any way. ... Have you also had HDD directory damage prevent a Mac booting from ...
    (uk.comp.sys.mac)
  • Re: Need Help Installing Debian on My Computer
    ... > My computer is capable of booting from the CD drive, ... > from the disk. ... When I try booting with the Debian i386 disk, ... > can boot from the CD drive because I can boot Knoppix 3.9. ...
    (Debian-User)
  • Re: Installation: doesnt see setup files on hard drive?
    ... > disk the BIOS is set to boot from must have an appropriate Master Boot ... I was worried about those points you made above so I removed all drives except the one I want to instll ...
    (microsoft.public.win2000.general)