Re: New VMS Audio update now available to start the week - ok for external



Sue wrote:
Don't forget to give your feedback after all you're the reason the
Audio team is doing this.


OK, I'll be brutal :-(

I've just caught up, listening from episode 3 through 7

First, I want to emphasise that I enjoy the broadcasts and value all contributors and the people who put it together. Since Sue has demanded comments, I and forced to find something to say, for fear of being duct taped again :-)

My worthless opinions are made randomly, not in any particular order of importance.

-Some of the sound effects and music could be made shorter. For instance, for the time change stuff, having clocks/bells last a few seconds would be enough. No need to emulate Pink Floyd's "Time" that starts with bells and chimes and clocks that last for a long time :-) (Note if I had listened to only the last episode, I probably would not have made that comment).

-Mr Hoff needs to speak louder. perhaps someone would just need to mention "porting VMS to the 8086" a few times just before he starts to record to get his blood pressure and voice volume to increase :-) :-) :-)

-Mr Khurt (sp?) pronounced Jean-François extremely well, "Pierronne" wasn't perfect but was more than good enough. His presentation/speaking skills are very good and make the broadcasts very entertaining. (how's that for a brutal criticisism ?)

-OK, this is a very general comment that applies to many segments. For example, the BACKUP /ENCRYPT. Instead of taking the time to describe various permutations for /ENCRYPT=, it might be better to simply mention that there are qualifiers to /ENCRYPT that lets you specify the encryption algorithm and to refer to on-line help to get them. An exception to this would be for undocumented parameters/qualifiers.

-Generally, I think each segment should be shorter. People shouldn't spell out URLs. Mr Khurt could simply end the segment by pointing that the URLs are all listed on the ____VMS.ORG website.

-It is neat to have speakers with different accents, including proper british english since it gives a more "global community" feeling.

-I don't like the term "webisode" or "podcast". "Episode" or "Installment" are fine and look more professional.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Finally some real Doctor Who on the radio
    ... Hearing Daleks quote Shakespeare took me so far ... for an awful episode. ... > it sounded like, well, an indistinct American accent. ... So even the crappiest ones are worth listening to at least for their ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: Vampiyan Kids
    ... Episode 16. ... Sue accidently turns Kou into a vampire. ... Papa swaps bodies with the Vampire Hunter guy. ...
    (rec.arts.anime.misc)
  • Re: JoJ Ep11 : A Fly Up The Nose
    ... are just stupid, come from nowhere, and I plan on talking with him ... It killed the episode for me. ... listening after the first 2 or 3 but I have and I've seen it improve quite ... At times I do wonder why you bother with another host; ...
    (rec.juggling)
  • Re: Torchwood on BBC Radio 4 - Wednesday afternoon
    ... Although BBC Radio doesn't have the ... happened to use the Torchwood characters and the CERN/LHC theme. ... minutes listening to it, but I was hoping for the kind of innovative ... I assume this episode will pop up somewhere ...
    (rec.arts.drwho)
  • Re: Trey Parker and Matt Stones response
    ... war for earth has just begun! ... So Comedy Central really pulled the episode? ... If you imply otherwise he'll SUE YOUR ASS. ... If electricity comes from electrons, ...
    (rec.sport.football.college)