Re: OT: TCP: trading latency for bandwidth

someone wrote:
By deficiencies, are you referring to the slow performance? I've always found the TCP/IP stacks on VMS to be incredibly sluggish. It's not just a bandwidth problem, it's very slow (relatively speaking) at reading and sending very small packets. The situation on a platform like Linux is quite different. It's very tragic.

At one point, I thought I was having IP performance problems on the link
and was using FTP as a means to check upload and download speeds (since
VMS doesn't have a working flash which is used for most speed tests).

ftp tests showed poor performance.

I did the same tests on my xserve (OS-X) and low and behold, the
performance difference was very drastic and make full use of the line
speed (showing the line had no problems).

I had already set a large TCPIP$FTP_WINDOW_SIZE (if I recall correctly)
and it didn't seem to make a difference.

There may be some paarmeters that can be set in TCPIP$ETC file
(systemconfig or something akin to this), but out of the box, the
performance was significantly lower than on OS-X (which came from freeBSD)

It is also possible that the FTP application was not properly ported and
fails to use any performance enhnacements possible on VMS.

The end result is that the peformance was sigificantly slower on VMS
than on OS-X.

Relevant Pages

  • Re: OS X Lion - breakdown of features, changes - appleinsider
    ... Bot FTP and NFS have mechanisms that allow transfers between two similar ... For instance, between 2 VMS systems, it is possible to FTP an indexed ... Note that at the command line, ...
  • Re: FTP - Get size of a file
    ... I wrote a Windows service to do exactly this for a major utility a ... FTP it is difficult to implement more advanced techniques such as CRC ... >} FTP server running on OpenVMS. ... I have no clue about VMS at all. ...
  • Re: FTP strangeness
    ... Which version of TCPIP and VMS are you running the ftp server under? ... So, it looks like SmartFTP is off the list as a client for VMS, Cerberus ...
  • Re: FTP sesion against a vms server fails
    ... rarely FTP from the "slow" system, ... Based on experience (rather than evidence), ... VMS IP stacks have their own packet-trace facilities too. ... For VMS there used to be the Vassar spelling checker; just don't rely on the spellings that students added to the dictionary!! ...
  • Re: OpenVMS FTP File Transfer issue
    ... > am having issues with the backup system. ... I tried to change the ftp server type to VMS and that didnt ... CuteFTP is a thorian horse that inserts spyware on your PC. ... I would ZIP the files on the VMS machine before transfering ...