Re: Hardware suggestion?

From: Glenn (glenn_at_IREPORTEVERYSPAMMER.canit.se)
Date: 12/23/03


Date: 23 Dec 2003 22:35:13 +0100


> + On 23-Dec-03 01:26:06
 +Will Hartung <willh@msoft.com> wrote

>Ideally, there will be a lot of caching, and the DB will be more write
>intensive than read intensive.

>So, obviously, I'm curious about hardware suggestions.

>Do y'all think v100s are too slow for this? The v120s offer pretty much the
>same thing, but with SCSI and hot swappable drives, and potentially more
>memory. Or do I need to move up to the v210?

Both the V120 and V210 is very nice machines, I would avoid the V100,
not that it's bad, but for a server I see mirrored disks as a min req.

>I like the idea of mirroring the drives for a minor stab at availability,
>but we don't have the budget to get completely redundant.

And mirroring with disksuite (or what sun call it this week) works fine
and is free.

[ Cut ]

>Should I consider a Intel 1/2U solution? Any that work well with Solaris
>x86? Punt and go Lintel? I'm not comfortable parting a 1U box together, and
>it is not clear that the Dells et al are dramatically better bang/buck. So,
>I'd rather stick with Sun hardware and Solaris.

We have both Sun and Dell servers at work and even if the dells work fine
I dont trust linux as much as Solaris.. also we had some strange problems
with dellmachines (some Poweredge, dont remember the model) that suddenly
lost one of the mirrored disks, after a call to dell they said "Ah, thats
a common problem, just remove the drive, boot, then shutdown and put the
same disk into the machine again and rebuild the mirror"

Aaargh, this is a server.. can't afford "common problems" that takes
half a day to recover..

Also dell wanted over a WEEK to replace a standard UWSCSI-cable that
another guy accidenticaly destroyed.. the call with dell was something like:

us: We want a scsicable that was destroyed asap, when can we have it ?
dell: you can have it in 12 days..
us: 12 DAYS ????
dell: Yes, there are no such cables in sweden..
us: But we have a servicecontract!
dell: Yes, but you destroyed it yourself..
us: Sure, we are going to pay it, but we need it NOW!
dell: Sorry, but we cant do anything about it..
us: But this is a server grade machine ?
dell: Yes..

Duh..

Fortunatly it was a standard cable so a serviceminded computerstore could
send one with expressdelivery so we had it 40 minutes later (the delivery
costed alot more than the cable itself), but I dont want to have the
same problem with some dell-specific part..

I dont say that this kind of stuff never happens with sun equipment, but
it havn't happened to me yet, and it lowered my trust in dell ALOT..



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Apple should buy SUN.
    ... You'll have to pay more for a slower, less efficient, Dell ... >>that offers less flexibility of software choices as compared to a new Sun. ... Cheapest rack-mount server I can see at Dell is $779. ... have tower servers for cheaper, ...
    (comp.unix.solaris)
  • Re: Ultra 20,24,and40
    ... But Sun does still sell it new currently. ... the Sun's have orders of magnitude better build quality. ... compare to the DELLs and HP boxes that were submitted to our ... The equivalent Dell was $500 more expensive and the ...
    (comp.sys.sun.hardware)
  • Re: New 32-bit (x86) computing options from Sun, Oracle, and Red Hat explained today.
    ... > Because Dell systems are generally crud. ... Meanwhile our DELL boxes keep on plugging away running FreeBSD. ... I'm really sick of Sun boxes that go "RED STATE EXCEPTION" and fall ...
    (comp.unix.solaris)
  • Re: Solaris and Linux comparison
    ... All the hard drives too- though I know Sun doesn't make ... These were technical conversations w/ Dell reps for a> $250,000 ... purchase of Dell hardware for a server room. ... OEM U1 fans are known to suck. ...
    (comp.unix.solaris)
  • Re: Opinions Wanted: Dell PowerEdge Servers ... ?
    ... My experience with Dell hardware and support goes back to the year ... Their enterprise support is by far THE ... The documentation that comes with the machines is far from ... PowerEdge 2850 and a Sun Fire X4200. ...
    (freebsd-questions)