Re: Archiving



J <skyliner306@xxxxxxxxx> writes:

Two beginner questions about archiving on Unix:

1. How reliable are tar and gzip compared to commercial archiving
products?

tar and gzip probably better in terms of reliability as they're open
source, widely available on a large number of bootable distributions,
and extremely mature.

But there are issues other than reliability... Commercial products
primarily bring convenience such that it becomes mroe likely backups
actually get performed, but if you take that out of the equation, tar,
gzip, rsync and cron can all be used for a wonderful backup solution
for a *nix or nix-like environment.

2. Assuming space is not an issue, is there any benefit in storing
compressed data? In other words, would my text, pdf, audio files
"keep" any better being tar'd and gzip'd first?

They'd keep better copied in their original hierarchy, as they'd be
more easily accessible, and there'd be no processing time associated
with accessing the archived data. But gzip is lossless
compression and barring media issues corrupting the archive it's just
a space tradeoff.

You don't mention any security aspects... if you're concerned about
maintaining the privacy of your data on backup media, you might
consider tar, gzip (or the more aggressive/intensive bzip2) and then
gpg encrypting the final archive.

--
Todd H.
http://www.toddh.net/
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Archiving
    ... Two beginner questions about archiving on Unix: ... How reliable are tar and gzip compared to commercial archiving ... Since tar does not do compression, ...
    (comp.unix.questions)
  • Re: Corruption
    ... $ tar tzvf ... However, when I nfs the files to another computer, I can tar & gzip the files, ... the test reports no errors and the difference test reports no differences. ... the archiving itself does not give any messages. ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: New Archiver called Scifer
    ... Bufferless Compression. ... Filtered Archiving. ... Why would I want to use a closed source tool if I have tar, gzip and ...
    (comp.compression)
  • AirLink NIC rhinefet.tar bad format fix
    ... I spotted some nic cards @US$6.99, ... tar: This does not look like a tar archive ... gzip compressed data, from Unix ... card as eth2 in thunderbird; meanwhile, vehicle has the card, and the ...
    (comp.os.linux.networking)
  • Re: moving a working fedora install from old to new hardware?
    ... I spose you could partition the new drive, ... Comparision of tar, cp and rsync for partition archiving ... If this option is present during creation it is not needed on restore! ...
    (Fedora)