Re: zfs on a SAN



Sanjay wrote:

Chris Cox <notccox@xxxxxxxxxxxxxx> wrote:


Fine.. Solaris will simply see a disk.. who cares if it's one or many,
raid or no raid.


According to the ZFS docs - ZFS cares and they recommend against using hardware
RAID.

It's a standardization issue for us - we have AIX, Windows & Solaris & EMC on the
backend.

The 3 other OS's will use the EMC the EMC hardware raid. This means that all the
EMCs going into our data centers will be configured (1+0 for expensive mission
critical and Clarriion w/RAID for low end).

At this point the SAN team - rightfully so wants to standardize on how they do raid
mirroring.

So I guess we'll just use ZFS without it's RAID features.


You can continue to use the hardware EMC raid.


Yeah - according to the ZFS docs it's not recommended. If it's not recommended I"m wondering
if it's not supported.

Well Sun is probably not going to support EMC RAID or anything else EMC. EMC gives you a bunch of LUNs that look like disks and act like disks. There is no way to tell the difference except for what EMC reports back as the drive type; ISTR that it just says it's an EMC drive even though the actual hardware might be IBM or Seagate or . . . . EMC does support it and that's what counts.

There is no point in asking ZFS to RAID or mirror EMC LUNs and I suspect that performance might suffer if you did. If, OTOH, you need a 5 terabyte volume, ZFS might put one together for you (don't know the details but I believe that ZFS uses enough bits to count some really humongous number of blocks.) I don't expect to ever have or need that much but some people do.
.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: zfs on a SAN
    ... ZFS works best when given whole physical disks. ... So with ZFS - would I be better off using the SAN for RAID? ... Why would you want to mirror or RAID the LUNs provided by the SAN? ... If something goes wrong with an EMC array, an engineer shows up, tells you he needs to repair it, and does so. ...
    (comp.unix.solaris)
  • Re: Needing advice about ZFS and SAN LUNs
    ... Within the EMC Box the three LUNs were generated from a RAID-5. ... As far as I know ZFS isn't supported by Sybase. ... layering software raid on top of hardware raid does ...
    (comp.unix.solaris)
  • Re: zfs on a SAN
    ... raid or no raid. ... According to the ZFS docs - ZFS cares and they recommend against using hardware ... The 3 other OS's will use the EMC the EMC hardware raid. ... Yeah - according to the ZFS docs it's not recommended. ...
    (comp.unix.solaris)
  • Re: raid is dangerous but thats secret (was Re: [patch] ext2/3:
    ... I seem to recall that ZFS does replicate metadata. ... partially-written RAID parity stripe. ...
    (Linux-Kernel)
  • zfs on a SAN
    ... else I'm pretty excited about it but I'm starting to see some potential problems. ... ZFS works best when given whole physical disks. ... volume manager, such as Solaris Volume Manager, Veritas Volume Manager, or a ... So with ZFS - would I be better off using the SAN for RAID? ...
    (comp.unix.solaris)