Use of automounter for permanent mounts?



One of my customers has a Web-based application on Solaris 9 with
several back-end NFS-mounted file libraries, which are (hard) mounted
in the usual way via /etc/vfstab.

Occasionally, one of the network links goes down or one of the NFS
servers fails. This results in processes that are using the NFS mount
hanging until the NFS server comes back. That isn't a problem except
that the failed mount has other side-effects such as a delay in
logging in to the system (I'm not sure why but something waits for a
time-out) and processes like "df -h" hang.

To avoid these issues, the customer has suggested that we replace all
these hard NFS mounts with NFS mounts controlled by the automounter.
The idea is that each mount will be set up with a symbolic link of the
form:

ln -s /net/host/path-to-library /mountpoint

and that a network or NFS server failure will affect only those
processes that are accessing the NFS mount without any unwanted
side-effects.

I'm dubious about this but I'm not sure why I feel that way. It may
just be that I remember that the automounter tended to be unreliable
some time ago and there's also the fact that it's (presumably)
intended to be used for occasional transient access to remote NFS
servers, not for permanent mounts.

Can anyone please comment on whether this proposal is sensible or
suggest good technical reasons why it isn't?

Mike.

.



Relevant Pages

  • Re: Cant edit text -
    ... word processor is nearly useless because I can't edit anything? ... Are the files on the local machine, or are they on an NFS mount? ... I don't remember how I copied them but I had all the old F-10 files on the nfs server and quite likely took them from there. ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: NFS
    ... lsof | grep <NFS server> works for me. ... by others over the NFS mount? ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: Delete question
    ... > In my NFS mount I have .Trash-501 which is where the files go when I ... > .Trash-501/files directory is empty. ... > to the trash when they are deleted. ... the NFS server for user 501. ...
    (alt.os.linux.suse)
  • Re: F12 NFS Failures
    ... This was using md5sum for about 10GB over the NFS mount ... The default for F12/Centos5.4 appears to be TCP - which freezes ... Forcing UDP gives NO errors for 10GB transfer ... I know this is an old thread, but I thought I'd toss in that you will see symptoms very much like this if only one of your machines (probably the NFS server) is configured to use jumbo frames. ...
    (Fedora)
  • Re: nfs permission problem
    ... Markus Grunwald wrote: ... when I do changes on a NFS mount. ... memberships on the NFS Server, ... To UNSUBSCRIBE, email to debian-user-REQUEST@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx ...
    (Debian-User)